Bab el-Mandeb vs the Strait of Hormuz

Two chokepoints, both disrupted, and almost nothing else in common. The difference that matters is that one has an alternative and the other does not.

Reviewed 9 November 2026

MeasureFigure
Hormuz — connectsPersian Gulf ↔ Gulf of Oman
Bab el-Mandeb — connectsRed Sea ↔ Gulf of Aden
Hormuz — narrowest width39 km (21 nautical miles)
Bab el-Mandeb — narrowest widthAbout 29 km (16 nautical miles)
Hormuz — oil, Q4 2025 → Q2 202621.6 → 4.9 million b/dEIA.
Bab el-Mandeb — oil, Q4 2025 → Q2 20265.4 → 8.1 million b/dRose, as Saudi crude rerouted to Red Sea terminals. EIA.
Hormuz — alternativeNone by sea; about a quarter by pipeline
Bab el-Mandeb — alternativeCape of Good Hope, 20+ extra days
Hormuz — restricted byIran, since February 2026
Bab el-Mandeb — restricted byHouthi forces

The one difference that drives everything else

Bab el-Mandeb is a shortcut. The Red Sea and Suez route exists because it is far quicker than going round Africa, and if the shortcut becomes unusable, ships take the long way. It costs more than 20 additional days at sea, a great deal of fuel, and enough extra ships to keep a service running at the same frequency — but it is available, it is predictable, and operators have been using it since 2024.

Hormuz is not a shortcut. It is the only opening in an enclosed sea. A cargo loaded at a Persian Gulf terminal has one way out, and no amount of willingness to sail further changes that. The alternatives that do exist are overland and cover roughly a quarter of normal volume.

Everything else follows. A Bab el-Mandeb disruption is expensive and absorbable; freight rates rise, schedules stretch, goods cost more. A Hormuz disruption is a supply problem, because the barrels and the cargoes of gas simply do not leave.

Side by side

Where the two are genuinely comparable, they are closer than their reputations suggest.

Width
Bab el-Mandeb is the narrower of the two, at about 29 km against Hormuz’s 39 km. Narrowness is not what makes Hormuz the more serious chokepoint — the absence of alternatives is.
Volume
Hormuz normally carries about 20 million barrels of oil a day against Bab el-Mandeb’s 5 to 8 million. But Bab el-Mandeb carries a much larger share of containerised and general cargo, because it is the Asia–Europe trunk route, so the two matter to different industries.
Cargo mix
Hormuz is dominated by liquid bulk: crude, products and about a fifth of global LNG trade. Bab el-Mandeb is mixed, with the Asia–Europe container trade alongside oil.
Who is disrupting it
Hormuz: Iran, through a permit regime enforced by attacks on unauthorised transits since February 2026. Bab el-Mandeb: Houthi forces, which took Yemen’s entire Red Sea coast including Perim Island in September 2026.
Legal position
Both are straits used for international navigation and both are subject to transit passage, which the bordering states may not suspend. In Hormuz that is being contested by a state; in Bab el-Mandeb the constraint comes from a non-state actor, which is a different problem for international law entirely.

Why 2026 made the comparison matter

Until this year the two were analytically separate: a Red Sea problem and a Gulf problem, with different causes and different industries watching them.

They stopped being separate when Gulf crude started rerouting. Saudi Arabia moved oil through the East-West pipeline to Yanbu on the Red Sea to avoid Hormuz — and a tanker loading at Yanbu has to leave the Red Sea, which means Bab el-Mandeb. The EIA data shows exactly this: Hormuz flow fell from 21.6 to 4.9 million barrels a day between the fourth quarter of 2025 and the second of 2026, while Bab el-Mandeb flow rose from 5.4 to 8.1 million over the same period.

So the main workaround for one disrupted chokepoint discharges into another disrupted chokepoint. That is new, and it is why most pre-2026 analysis of Hormuz bypass capacity overstates the available relief. The compounding is set out here.

Common questions

Which is more important, Hormuz or Bab el-Mandeb?
Hormuz, for energy security — larger volumes and no alternative route. Bab el-Mandeb matters more for the Asia–Europe container trade, where it carries a much larger share of general cargo.
Which is narrower?
Bab el-Mandeb, at about 29 km against 39 km for Hormuz at its narrowest. Narrowness is not the measure of a chokepoint’s importance.
Can ships avoid both?
Bab el-Mandeb, yes — via the Cape of Good Hope, at more than 20 extra days. Hormuz, no, unless the cargo leaves the Gulf by pipeline and loads outside the strait.
Are both currently disrupted?
Yes, for unrelated reasons. Hormuz has been under Iranian transit control since February 2026; Bab el-Mandeb has been affected by Houthi operations, with transits well below their pre-disruption level.

Sources

Strait Insider is a reference site, not a news wire. Developing events are summarised with a link to the reporting they come from; follow the source for the current position.